East-West Comparative Philosophy II

Let us pick up where we left off comparative philosophy (pointing towards a synthetic world philosophy). I have made a table giving a quick comparative analysis (using specific parameters such as epistemology, metaphysics, Life's ideal, man's ultimate nature, civilization and cultures, evolution etc) of the three main philosophical traditions.

In simple words, if we were to take the three traditions together, we find three overall standpoints of their philosophies:

1. The inward (Indian) : The most important characteristic is the reflective inwardness and Intuition. Intuition being naturally coexistent and continuous with intellect yet a faculty of wider cognition and working without the distinction. Indian philosophy, particularly the dominant Vedanta and the highest forms of Buddhism, recognized the possibility of mind's witnessing itself (through higher grades or categories of self, the intuitive mind being one of them), through which it can realize the grand conscious unity underlying the universe and extending far beyond it. It termed the grand conscious unity witnessed coining words such as Divine, Absolute, Brahman, Vijiidna, Tathata, Nirvana, and so on.

2. The outward (Western) : In western philosophy also, the Neo-Platonists, the great Christian mystics, and some of the idealistic philosophers recognized some of those deeper truths of inwardness. But if one takes the dominant trends and contemporary achievements into consideration, one finds that its major accomplishment lies in liberating the object, or outwardness, from its involvement with the subject, or inwardness. Of the two directions, the outward has received deeper attention in western philosophy.

3. The middle (Chinese) : The overall impression Chinese philosophy (except Buddhism) gives is that it is neither deeply inward nor extremely outward. It has always tried keeping a balance between the two, and is more comfortable with "Man in society" than with ultimate problems of inwardness or outwardness. Overall no direction is pursued to the extreme; no argument is pressed to its logical conclusions.

Attached: Introductory comparative table of three major philosophical systems – Indian (The inward), Western (The Outward), and Chinese (The Middle), summarized from Book “Introduction to comparative philosophy” by P. T. Raju.

Comments

The Yoga of Synthesis Diary Leaves 4

Album The Yoga of Synthesis Dated 22 January 2025 The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali give us four stages of meditation and when applied on symbols we find: 1. First, as the form is pondered upon, the realisation begins to dawn that it is but a symbol of an inner reality. 2. Second, there is a recognition of the quality or nature of the form—its subjective energy, the quality of the force that seems to flow through it, the emotion that the symbol arouses. 3. Third, as we concentrate on considering the quality, we arrive next at the purpose, the motive, and the idea that the symbol has held concealed. 4. Fourth, in the final stage of identification, one becomes at one with the symbol; one shares its quality; one participates in its purpose, and through these stages one arrives at a unity with the creator of the form. When applied to the four symbols (of Helena Blavatsky, Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, Alice Bailey, and the category-theoretic model of Cause-Meaning/Quality-Effect), we...

A synthesis of Savitri and Theosophy - Painting No 15

Today we continue to contemplate on the remaining lines from Page 5 of the Symbol Dawn of Savitri. "Here too the vision and prophetic gleam Lit into miracles common meaningless shapes; Then the divine afflatus, spent, withdrew, Unwanted, fading from the mortal’s range. A sacred yearning lingered in its trace, The worship of a Presence and a Power Too perfect to be held by death-bound hearts, The prescience of a marvellous birth to come." 'Here' stands for our ordinary human world where the vision and prophetic brief light of Goddess lit the ordinary shapes miraculously into divine meaning for few moments. But then the divine creative impulse or inspiration was spent and feeling unwanted withdrew and faded from the range of mortal men. Once gone it left behind a sacred yearning in the hearts of those later realized what had happened. The presence and Power of Divine Goddess was too perfect to be worshipped to be held steady by death-bound hearts of ordinary mortals. ...

A Lam-Rim Retreat - Part III

Dated May/June 2025. 1. A Darshan As we meditated and learned some key concepts of Mahayana Buddhism, the air within the monastery was mildly perfumed with the delicate scent of Tibetan essence. Outside, the bees hummed among the native flowers, intoxicated by their fragrance. On the nearby trees, the monkeys leaped and swung, and the outside air was filled with the chirp of small birds and insects. Deceived by material prosperity and addicted to comforts (I am not against either of these, but against the ever-increasing production of goods or the culture of consumerism to gratify men's insatiable desires; or to hide the unpleasant facts of life), the majority of "modernistic" men have deprived themselves of the opportunity and privileges of leading a truly satisfying life of spiritual freedom as their ancestors once did. As I took a Tibetan Buddhist retreat on the Himalayan heights, I could readily experience that it was immensely easier for the materially “ba...

Wisdom Yoga of Synthesis - The Blaze of Non-Dual BodhiChitta

Search This Blog