Skip to main content

East-West Comparative Philosophy III

 Subsequent to the discussion on the comparative philosophy, this post alludes to a synthesis of East, West philosophies leading to Synthetic global philosophy.


As a prelude to the synthesis, let me recall these words of Sri Aurobindo in context of synthesis of ancient Vedantic Yoga philosophies,


"The synthesis we propose cannot, then, be arrived at either by combination in mass or by successive practice. It must there- fore be effected by neglecting the forms and outsides of the Yogic disciplines and seizing rather on some central principle common to all which will include and utilise in the right place and proportion their particular principles, and on some central dynamic force which is the common secret of their divergent methods and capable therefore of organising a natural selection and combination of their varied energies and different utilities." (The Synthesis of Yoga, Volume 23, Collected Works Sri Aurobindo)


One can extend this essence of synthesis into the domain of comparative philosophies where, seizing universal ideals on some central principle common to all (such as Beauty, Goodness, and Truth and every man on earth being allowed to live the fullest inward as well as outward life possible, realizing all the values of life, and enjoying all the human rights) which will include and utilise in the right place and proportion their particular principles. Here divergent differences will not be completely annihilated; but they will acquire right proportion. Values unknown to some cultures will be introduced to them; and if they resonate to the chord of synthetic truth, they will be welcomed with enthusiasm.


Definitely, every man in every country is not a philosopher. But in a limited field his problems get generally solved by leaders. Such leaders will then have a wider perspective than today, offered by synthetic global philosophy. It is for developing the conception of a fuller richer life that a synthetic philosophy is needed, not for cultural dominance of the rest by some part of the world.



Lauding the contribution of such a philosophy P.T Raju says:


"If human life is essentially the same everywhere, if all values of life are to be made accessible to all men, then every culture will develop philosophies that bear essential similarities in thought, outlook, and aim. The aim of comparative philosophy is such cultural synthesis, which implies not dominance but development, not imposition but assimilation, not narrowing of outlook but its broadening, and not limitation of life but its expansion." 


Acknowledging the 'common secret of divergent methods and capable therefore of organising a natural selection and combination of their varied energies and different utilities' he says,


"Philosophical variety is interesting only because the problems of any culture can be problems of all the rest in a more or less pronounced form. If they are less pronounced, imagination knows how to lift them to the level of acuteness and feel their importance. For that very reason, they are comparable, not incomparable. The richness of philosophical variety is not lost if all the real and important problems of life felt everywhere in the world are brought together. Even if the philosopher refuses to do it, actual life does bring them together when cultures meet. If a personal God is necessary for religious consciousness in the West, He is necessary for religious consciousness in India also; and an overwhelming majority of Indians worship a personal God, even when many describe Him as impersonal. If sympathy, human- heartedness, and other such qualities are necessary for a happy social life in China and are even the basis of political life there, they are equally necessary for the West and India. If rational analysis is necessary for understanding man, society, and their environment in the West, it is equally necessary for India and China. If humanism is incomplete without spiritual roots in India, it will be equally incomplete in China and the West."


Further allaying the common fear of a concrete mind especially loss of uniqueness he says,


"Our fear should not be about cultures becoming alike all the world over, but about ignorance, intolerance, and arrogance preventing any life or culture from developing to its full. Full life everywhere does not mean absolute uniformity in every detail. The ideals of Beauty, Goodness, and Truth are everywhere the same. But the peculiarity of each culture lies in how those are embodied in it, and whether they are embodied fully and properly, and also how its members react to them with their sensations, emotions, affections, and volitions. If man is essentially the same everywhere, life's highest ideals also will be the same. If life is full and complete everywhere, differences assume secondary importance."


Such a synthetic philosophy is depicted using Roberto Assagioli's triangle of synthesis.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Yoga of Synthesis Diary Leaves 4

 Album The Yoga of Synthesis  Dated 22 January 2025 The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali give us four stages of meditation and when applied on symbols we find: 1. First, as the form is pondered upon, the realisation begins to dawn that it is but a symbol of an inner reality. 2. Second, there is a recognition of the quality or nature of the form—its subjective energy, the quality of the force that seems to flow through it, the emotion that the symbol arouses. 3. Third, as we concentrate on considering the quality, we arrive next at the purpose, the motive, and the idea that the symbol has held concealed. 4. Fourth, in the final stage of identification, one becomes at one with the symbol; one shares its quality; one participates in its purpose, and through these stages one arrives at a unity with the creator of the form. When applied to the four symbols (of Helena Blavatsky, Sri Aurobindo and The Mother, Alice Bailey, and the category-theoretic model of Cause-Meaning/Quality-Effect), we...
Post a Comment
Read more

A synthesis of Savitri and Theosophy - Painting No 15

 Today we continue to contemplate on the remaining lines from Page 5 of the Symbol Dawn of Savitri.  "Here too the vision and prophetic gleam Lit into miracles common meaningless shapes; Then the divine afflatus, spent, withdrew, Unwanted, fading from the mortal’s range. A sacred yearning lingered in its trace, The worship of a Presence and a Power Too perfect to be held by death-bound hearts, The prescience of a marvellous birth to come." 'Here' stands for our ordinary human world where the vision and prophetic brief light of Goddess lit the ordinary shapes miraculously into divine meaning for few moments. But then the divine creative impulse or inspiration was spent and feeling unwanted withdrew and faded from the range of mortal men. Once gone it left behind a sacred yearning in the hearts of those later realized what had happened. The presence and Power of Divine Goddess was too perfect to be worshipped to be held steady by death-bound hearts of ordinary mortals. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Seeds of synthesis

Some of the seeds of synthesis I have discovered (experiments are ongoing to give fair consideration and enlighten ourselves) so far between sciences, religions, philosophies are listed below for the lovers of truth and wisdom - Synthesis of mathematics - Category theory (Grothendieck, Saunders Maclane) Synthesis of religions - Theosophy (Helena Blavatsky) (A mathematical expression of the law of Karma or cause and effect is in my thesis) Synthesis of philosophies and Human Knowledge itself - A treatise on seven rays (24 Books of Djwal Khul and Alice Bailey) Synthesis of pyschology - Psychosynthesis (Roberto Assagioli), Humanistic astrology and soul-centred psychology (Dane Rudhyar, Alan Oken) Synthesis of ancient systems of Yoga - Synthesis of Yoga (Sri Aurobindo),Auroville (Experiment of synthesising city), Agni Yoga (Nicholas and Helena Roerich) Synthesis of agriculture - Permaculture (Masanobu Fukuoka) Synthesis of signal representation - Functorial Signal Representation Synthesi...
Post a Comment
Read more